Top this dinner fail, I dare ya.

For Sunday dinner, I lovingly prepared freshly killed chickens baked with root vegetables in butter.

I took the birds, slaughtered the previous day, rinsed them as usual, put them in the pot and baked until done.

It all looked fine. We sat down to eat. I took my chef’s knife and cut up the birds. When I cut the first one it smelled … not right. I put my nose close and only smelled herbs and chicken. It seemed odd. What could possibly be wrong with a chicken that was so freshly killed, kept on ice, put in the fridge and then baked? I shrugged and served up the food.

Everything was fine until my husband took a bite of his. “WHAT DID YOU PUT IN THIS?” he gagged.

“Um… basil and rosemary… some butter… salt…?”

“Something is terribly wrong.”

He went to the kitchen to spit and came to show me what was on his fork. At first it looked like it could be a clump of cooked herbs. But as he came closer he and I both realized that it was much, much worse than that.

It was a forkful of chicken poo.

“I just ate chicken s***,” he kept saying, dazed.

He felt a little sick.

I still don’t exactly know what internal organ I was supposed to have checked and cleaned properly. But believe me, I will be halving the raw birds and checking them out thoroughly before cooking next time.

When there is a next time, that is. I’m pretty sure it will be a while before my poor traumatized husband can eat chicken again. Good thing our cow comes in next week.

Go ahead, tell me your kitchen failure.   Does it top this?

This entry was posted in Cooking. Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Top this dinner fail, I dare ya.

  1. Oh…ew!!!! Your poor husband! Ha ha! I don’t think I have any stories that can top that one!

  2. Jennifer Edlund says:

    With all the other things he’s eaten, you would think that might not phase him so much. I’m so sorry. And you are right, that does trump me serving nearly raw chicken to a large group of family when I was 12.

  3. Katherine Lauer says:

    That does sound like a doozy! Woo-ee!

  4. Erin Turntine says:

    Oh wow! That is just awful for Dave, but also something I can’t stop laughing about. I hope he’s not scarred for life!

  5. Jessica says:


    One time we had company and and made wings and gave almost a dozen people food sickness from both ends. Including myself and my hubby and a guest who was staying with us. Thankfully the wings were so spicy that no children had tried them, and we had three bathrooms.

  6. Mandy says:

    Oh no! That’s so something that I would do! Sorry that happened, but boy did it give me a chuckle. 😀 Hope it goes better next time.

  7. sheila0405 says:

    I forgot to take the shot out of a pheasant, once, that my husband had shot for dinner. No one got sick, and thankfully, no broken teeth, either!

  8. elaine says:

    that is hysterical.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s